Is my PPC agency any good?
You pay the invoice every month. The report says things are fine. And you have no idea whether they are. You can start finding out today, from the account itself: the report is produced by the people being judged, but Google Ads keeps its own record.
Across every account I've taken over from an agency, the good, the bad and the ugly, what stands out first is how well the agency understood the business: what it sells, and who its best customers are. It shows in the details. The keywords, the search terms you're paying for, the negative keywords (or the lack of them), the ad copy, what's counted as a conversion, the location targeting. Each one is a clue to how well someone knew the business. And from the agency's side it makes sense: if you're managing dozens of accounts across B2B and B2C, different industries, small firms and enterprise, how well can you understand them all?
Every one of those clues sits in the account, where you can read it yourself. The platform keeps receipts; you just need to know which drawers to open. If the reports look great and you're still not convinced, skip ahead to what's being counted as a conversion.
Three questions before you even log in
- Is the account yours? If campaigns live in the agency's Google Ads account and you leave, the history (years of conversion data) stays with them. Ask directly: "Is the account under our billing, and do we keep it if we part ways?" A pause is an answer.
- Can you log in right now? You should have at least read-only access, permanently. "We'll send you a report instead" is not access.
- Do you know the split? How much went to Google last month, and how much to the agency? If one invoice bundles both into a single number, ask for the split. Refusal is a red flag with no innocent explanation.
Fee context while you're at it: UK management runs £200–£800 a month freelance, £500–£5,000+ agency-side, with a published median around £470. Those bands track account size, and complex accounts sit well above the median. Being at the top of that range isn't a problem. Being at the top of it with what you find below is.
Check the change history
Log in. Go to Campaigns → Change history (Google Ads Help, checked 30 October 2026) and set the date range to the last 90 days. This takes two minutes.
Google Ads logs changes to the account (bid changes, negative keywords, new ads, budget moves) against the date and the login that made them, going back two years. It's the one report the agency doesn't control.
What you want: steady, purposeful activity. A handful of considered changes most weeks: search-term exclusions, ad copy tests, budget adjustments with a pattern to them.
What you sometimes find: nothing. Weeks of it. Or only changes logged to an automated system, while no person has touched the account since onboarding. On an account billed hundreds a month for "active management", a silent change history is the clearest evidence of neglect you can gather. Screenshot it before your next review call.
Read the search terms
The quickest giveaway, and the easiest to spot, is the search terms. Read down them and ask how relevant each one is to what you actually sell, and to who you actually sell it to.
Go to Campaigns → Insights and reports → Search terms (Google Ads Help, checked 30 October 2026), set the last 90 days, sort by cost and filter to zero conversions. You're looking at the actual searches your money bought. Allow ten minutes for a quick search-term check.
Some waste is normal: paid search is probabilistic. What shouldn't be there: obviously irrelevant queries with real spend against them. Job seekers. Free-version hunters. Other cities. Other industries. If the same junk terms have been drinking budget for months, nobody's reading this report, and it's typically 10–25% of total spend in accounts that have never had a systematic search-term review.
Check what counts as a conversion
If the reports look great and you're still not convinced, the likely culprit is what's being counted as a conversion. I'd go through that with you, though I'd need full access to the account and to Tag Manager to confirm anything.
You can make a start yourself. Go to Goals → Conversions → Summary (Google Ads Help, checked 30 October 2026). Only genuine outcomes (enquiries, purchases, calls of real length) should be set as Primary, because primary actions are the ones in the Conversions column of every report and, when their goal is used for bidding, the ones Google's bidding algorithm works towards. Page views and button clicks counted as conversions make every number in the report flattering and false. The usual tracking faults are worth a read before the call.
Ask for results without your own brand name
Ask what performance looks like with searches for your own company name stripped out. Brand clicks are cheap and would mostly have found you anyway; blending them in is how a mediocre quarter is dressed as a good one. An agency that reports the split unprompted is being straight with you.
Read the ads as your customer would
One more check: the ad copy. With experience, you can spot generic against specific in seconds. Without it, read the ads as if you were the customer and ask one question: could a competitor run this word for word? A specific ad quotes figures where they matter, says precisely what's on offer, tells the wrong customer it isn't for them, asks for one clear next step, and uses the words the customer actually searched. Google's own guidance says the same: generic calls to action "often show decreased engagement with ads".
| The lever | Specific | Generic |
|---|---|---|
| A figure, not an adjective | Combi Boilers Fitted £1,895 | Quality Boiler Installation |
| A precise promise | 10-Year Warranty Included | Trusted Local Experts |
| It qualifies who should click | Leeds Homeowners Only | Get a Free Quote Today |
| One clear next step | Book a Survey This Week | Contact Us Now |
| The words the customer searched | Combi Boiler Replacement | Heating Services |
Four questions for the next review call
Not gotchas: working questions a competent manager answers easily, in plain English. Jargon in response to any of them is itself information (a translation table, if you need one).
- "What did you change last month, and why?" Should match the change history you just read.
- "What's our cost per new customer, excluding brand?" The only number that connects ads to the P&L.
- "Who actually works on our account, and how much time did we get?" You were probably sold by someone senior. Who has the login now?
- "What would you do with 20% less budget?" A good answer names specific cuts. "Results would drop proportionally" means nobody knows where the margin is, or the fee's a percentage of spend and the incentive is showing.
What isn't their fault
Fair's fair. Some of what looks like agency failure isn't:
- Your landing page. They can buy the right click; they can't make your site convert it. If they've flagged page problems in writing and nothing changed, that's on you.
- Lead handling. Enquiries answered two days later die. No campaign fixes that.
- Seasonality and market shifts. A competitor doubling bids moves your numbers with no one at fault. Auction insights show it plainly.
- Tracking they warned you about. If broken measurement was raised and deferred, the fog is a decision you made.
The test isn't whether performance dipped. It's whether they told you why, in writing, before you asked.
Leave slowly over performance, quickly over silence
A new account fairly needs 60–90 days to prove itself, and a decent agency deserves the chance to answer what you've found: most of these problems are fixable by the incumbent, and switching has real costs.
But evidence of work should be visible from week one. If the change history is empty, the search terms are a landfill, and the answers to plain questions arrive wrapped in fog, the 90-day rule doesn't apply. It protects effort, not absence.
Quick answers
What does a good job look like?
Check evidence of work, not just results. In Google Ads, the change history shows the changes made to the account, who made them and when: a well-run account shows regular, purposeful changes; an abandoned one shows weeks of silence or only automated edits. Then check the search terms report for expensive irrelevant queries, confirm only real business outcomes are set as primary conversions, and ask for performance reported with brand campaigns separated from non-brand.
Where is last month's work recorded?
Google Ads logs changes under Change history (Campaigns → Change history), with who made each one and when. Filter to the last 30 or 90 days and look at the volume, the type of changes, and who made them. Weeks with no manual changes on an actively billed account are the single clearest sign of neglect. You need at least read-only access to look, and if you don't have that, request it today.
What belongs in a monthly report?
Conversions, cost per conversion or acquisition, and revenue or lead quality against target (with brand and non-brand separated), plus what was changed during the month, what the result was, and what's planned next. Impressions, clicks and click-through rate are diagnostics, not results. A report built mainly on those is describing activity, not performance.
What are the red flags?
The campaigns live in the agency's account rather than yours, so you lose the history if you leave. You can't log in. The invoice bundles ad spend and fee into one number. Reporting leads with impressions and clicks. The fee is a percentage of spend and the recommendation is always to spend more. Lock-in contracts of twelve months or longer. Any one of these is worth a conversation; several together are worth a second opinion.
How long before leaving?
Distinguish time-to-results from evidence-of-work. A new account fairly needs 60–90 days to prove itself. But evidence of work (regular changes in the change history, search terms being reviewed, questions answered plainly) should be visible from week one. Leave slowly over performance, quickly over silence.
A paid audit of the whole account
In a fixed-fee audit, I run the checks above plus the structural ones across your whole account, rank the findings by what they cost you, and send them in a document you can use with your current agency, a new one or in-house. It starts with a free intro call, and if the checks above have already answered your question, I'll be transparent and tell you an audit isn't needed right now.